- 2021 – Lucas DeMeo, Harborfields High School
- 2020 – Matthew Campo, Mount Sinai High School
- 2019 – Joey Slackman, Commack High School
- 2018 – Joseph Franzese, John Glenn High School
- 2017 – James Hoeg, Mattituck High School
- 2016 – Matteo DeVincenzo, Port Jefferson High School
- 2015 – Thomas Dutton, Rocky Point High School
- 2014 – Bryan Wehner, Smithtown West High School
- 2013 – Alex Tanzman, Westhampton Beach High School
- 2012 – Branson Berger, Smithtown East High School
- 2011 – Frank Abbondanza, Mount Sinai High School
- 2010 – Steve Dutton, Rocky Point High School
- 2009 – Steve Keith, Shoreham Wading River High School
- 2008 – Mike Castellano, John Glenn High School
- 2007 – Corey Jantzen, Shoreham Wading River High School
- 2006 – Mike Piccirillo, Commack High School
- 2005 – Jack Sullivan, Huntington High School
- 2004 – Jason Siegelheim, Half Hollow Hills West High School
- 2003 – Steve Hromada, Half Hollow Hills East High School
- 2002 – Dan Miracola, Shoreham Wading River High School
- 2001 – Mike Roth, Half Hollow Hills West High School
- 2000 – Kyle Bernholtz, Mount Sinai High School
- 1999 – Joel Barone, William Floyd High School
- 1998 – Chris Felicetta, Bellport High School
- 1997 – Paul Buchnor
